Examining the development of national procedural mechanisms to resolve a trail smelter type dispute. The smelter in trail, british columbia was historically operated by the consolidated mining and. Trail operations is carrying out remedial investigation and feasibility studies in the upper columbia river area. The tail smelter located in british columbia since 1906, was owned and. It found that under the principles of international law, as well as of the law of the. Rural medical practice in the smelter west, 18981923. The trail smelter case1 arose in the field of late 1950s and came up with the issue of international environmental law. The duty to protect other states against harmful acts by individuals from within its. Max planck encyclopedia of public international law, 2007. In conclusion, the tribunal answers question 1 in article iii, as follows. Examining the development of national procedural mechanisms to resolve a trail smelter type dispute article pdf available june 2011 with 295 reads. Encyclopaedic dictionary of international law authors.
From 1925, at least, to the end of 1931, damage occurred in the state of washington, resulting from the sulphur dioxide emitted from the trail smelter. Convention between canada and the united states of america relating to certain complaints arising from the operation of the smelter at trail, british columbia ottawa, april 15th, 1935. The first fur nace was started in february, 1896, and before the end of the year the plant was m complete operation. Awards 1905 1941, including the facts, issue, rule of law, holding and reasoning, key terms, and concurrences and dissents. The trailhead is located on the west side of highway 550160 just south of santa rita park. As a result of smelting operations of a canadian company at trail, in british columbia, canada, sulphur dioxide. Customary international law aaron schwabach encyclopedia of life support systems eolss harm of this nature includes global warming and destruction of the ozone layer, marine. This was the first decision to recognize international liability for damages caused to another nation, even when no existing treaty created an obligation to prevent such damage. The trail smelter case essay writing service hire a. The trail smelter case1 arose in the field of late 1950s and came up with the issue of. Mar, 2018 an overview of the trail smelter case that decided that states were responsible for the damages caused in another state by pollution emanating from private entities. More than 78 years ago, the trail smelter tribunal heralded a new era in the field of international environmental law, establishing the principle of transboundary harm.
The trail smelter case of 1926 to 1934 is important in the study of. Trail smelter case united states, canada 16 april 1938 and 11 march 1941 volume iii pp. Trail smelter case united states v canada informea. The trail smelter dispute was a transboundary pollution case involving the federal governments of both canada and the united states, which eventually contributed to establishing the harm principle in the environmental law of transboundary pollution the smelter in trail, british columbia was historically operated by the consolidated mining and smelting company until cominco merged with teck. Trail smelter case pols 3201 international law youtube. To date, the studies have generally shown that the water in the river system meets applicable water quality standards in both canada and the united states, that the beaches are safe for recreational activities, and that the fish in the river system are as safe or safer to eat than. Towards an international ecological law and organization 50 1979 describing the trail smelter arbitration as a. Trail smelter case united states, canada, awards of 16 april 1938 and 11 march 1941, united nations, reports of international arbitral awards, vol. Serpa soares, delivered opening remarks and moderated a side event on the choice of procedure under article 287 of the united nations convention on the law of the sea, organized by the division for ocean affairs and the law of the sea, office of legal affairs, on the margins of the twentyseventh meeting. The city of trail is located on the columbia river in the west kootenay region of british columbia, canada, about ten kilometres north of the canadaunited states border. The trail smelter dispute was a transboundary pollution case involving the federal governments of both canada and the united states, which eventually contributed to establishing the harm principle in the environmental law of transboundary pollution. Pil the trail smelter arbitration popwerpoint presentation. Trail creek, running through the town, was culverted and the gully filled with smelter slag, doubling the building area of the downtown area.
An overview of the trail smelter case that decided that states were responsible for the damages caused in another state by pollution emanating from private entities. Trail smelter united states of america canada 1938. The corpus of international law which relates to the environment now consists of the general obligation of states to ensure that activities within their jurisdiction and control respects the environment of other states or areas beyond national control. Trail smelter united states of america canada 1938 and. Des procedures ulterieures eurent lieu entre les parties en vertu dun accord spe. Variations on a theme 89 2002 stating that the trail smelter case is one of the. In this case it was damage caused by one state to the environment of the other that triggered the legal. Gabcikovonagymaros project hungaryslovakia case brief. Smelter mountain trail for exact direction to the trailhead simply click on the smelter mountain trailhead in the map above and select the link directions. The duty to protect other states against harmful acts by individuals from within its jurisdiction at all times is the responsibility of a state. Sep 17, 2015 trail smelter arbitration case united states vs canada 1941, u.
The trail smelter arbitration smelting international. The trail smelter arbitration1 occupies a strange place in international environmental law. To get there turn west onto the frontage road just south of the bridge crossing the animas river, take the first right onto cr 210 and then. The trail smelter dispute was a transboundary pollution case involving the federal. In the event that no two members of the tribunal agree on a. Jan 25, 2012 the trail smelter tribunal navigated this clash of sovereignties by articulating what have come to be known as the trail smelter principles. In this case it was damage caused by one state to the environment of the other read more. The trail smelter arbitration v2 international law. The trail smelter arbitration smelting international law. The trail is steep and youll gain over 1,000 feet of elevation gain in less than a mile.
The states then had to take recourse to the tribunal in the absence of a proper forum. Trail smelter case united states, canada, 3 unriaa, p. The trail smelter arbitration v2 free download as powerpoint presentation. Trail smelter, procedural mechanisms, transboundary pollution, dispute settlement. The book brings the trail smelter episode to life in all its uniqueness and complexity and explores. In 1935 a canadian based corporation defendant owned a smelter plant which emitted hazardous fumes sulfur dioxide that caused damage to plant life, forest trees, soil, and crop yields accross the border in washington state in the united states plaintiff. Variations on a theme 89 2002 stating that the trail smelter case is one of the landmarks of the traditional period to which scholars constantly refer. Pdf this article reexamines the iconic trail smelter dispute. A summary and case brief of trail smelter arbitration united states v.
The first suggestion t trail smelter, came in the late autumn of 1925, from mr. Copper and gold smelting operations began in the area in 1896, and the teck cominco metals ltd. Transboundary environmental harm and state responsibility. In the 1920s, concern arose in north american medical circles that both the quantity and quality of doctors in rural practice were declining. Gabcikovonagymaros project hungaryslovakia case brief rule of law. The same year a convention established an arbitral tribunal consisting of two national members. The trail smelter was one of the best and largest equipped smelting plants on this continent trail smelter arbitration, 1938. The most famous case about transboundary pollution in public international law is known as trail smelter. It had now been turned over to the world of international institutions. As a result there was an animosity between northport and trail that originated in the contrasting and uneven economic development occurring on either side of the. Gradually improvements to the smelter increased production and employment in trail.
The trail smelter case top rated essay writing service. Doctors withdrawal from the countryside was accompanied by a flow of. Merkourios international and european environmental law vol. The trail smelter arbitration1937 linkedin slideshare. The trail smelter arbitration united statescanada would undoubtedly be characterised as a landmark case, particularly if the principal criterion for such status is subsequent repetition leading to widespread and nearuniversal endorsement. Teck cominco leadzinc smelter, trail, bc trail, british columbia. The pollution from the smelter at trail was no longer a local issue. This tribunal is constituted under, and its powers are derived from and. The trail smelter case reexamined utrecht journal of. The article discusses the way a modern day trail smelter type dispute would be. The trail smelter arbitration of 1938 and 1941 was a landmark decision about a dispute over environmental degradation between the united states and canada. The unique nature of the procedural resolution to the trail smelter dispute raises the issue of how a similar dispute would be dealt with today.
The trail smelter tribunal navigated this clash of sovereignties by articulating what have come to be known as the trail smelter principles. This was the first decision to recognize international liability for damages caused to another nation, even when no existing treaty created an obligation to. Of specific interest is the emphasis put on human rights, and the emphatic defence of the argument that the netherlands also has a duty of care visavis damage occurring elsewhere in particular. Other articles where trail smelter arbitration is discussed. Unesco eolss sample chapters international law and institutions transboundary environmental harm and state responsibility. As early as 1925 and there is some evidence earlier suggestions were made to the trail smelter that damage was being done to property in the northern part of stevens county. Although these trail smelter principles have become customary international environmental law, the arbitration itself is often viewed as a quaint remnant of a bygone world.
1243 540 592 431 1300 513 1226 634 45 289 298 258 726 79 1304 901 481 1145 1342 343 622 171 1222 304 662 965 894 839 519 267 965 318 413